Let’s talk about something we all use (hopefully) every day: toothpaste. More specifically, let’s talk about fluoride toothpaste. It lines store shelves, is handed out at dentist visits, and gets promoted in nearly every mainstream dental guidebook.
If you’ve ever been to the dentist and dared to question fluoride, chances are you got a rehearsed answer about how fluoride is “proven to strengthen enamel” and “reduce cavities.” And to be fair, it does do those things. That’s not really up for debate.
What is up for debate, however, and becoming harder to ignore, is the long list of concerns surrounding fluoride’s effects on our health, especially for children and pregnant women. Yet, despite this growing body of concern, dental schools are still teaching the same fluoride-forward protocol, and many dentists are doubling down on recommending it. Why?
Let’s break it all down from what fluoride actually does, to why it’s being questioned, and whether there might be another way to protect our teeth without sacrificing our health.
What Is Fluoride and Why Is It in Toothpaste?
Fluoride is a mineral found in water, soil, and some foods. It’s been added to drinking water and toothpaste since the mid-20th century to help reduce tooth decay. When used topically (like in toothpaste), fluoride helps to remineralize enamel, making teeth more resistant to acid and bacteria.
That’s why fluoride toothpaste became the gold standard. For decades, it has been touted as the reason cavity rates dropped in industrialized countries. But is it the reason? That’s where things get murky.
What Dentists Are Still Being Taught
Dental students are still learning that fluoride is the #1 way to prevent cavities. In fact, it’s such a staple in dental education that questioning it often results in raised eyebrows or worse – being seen as someone who’s into “pseudoscience.” Most dental programs don’t leave much room for nuance. The message is clear in these programs: fluoride is safe, effective, and essential.
That message is then passed down to patients in the form of fluoride toothpaste recommendations, fluoride treatments during cleanings, and even prescription-strength fluoride pastes for those deemed “high-risk” for cavities.
But here’s the thing: the education dentists receive is largely based on industry-supported research. Just like in medicine, the dental field can sometimes fall victim to biased studies, incomplete data, and outdated protocols. Science has evolved in many other areas of health, so why hasn’t oral care caught up?
The Elephant in the Room: Fluoride Health Concerns
Let’s get real for a second and share that fluoride is not risk-free. And the concern isn’t just from “crunchy” or alternative health circles anymore. Mainstream research has started to raise red flags too.
Here are just a few of the concerns:
- Neurotoxicity: Some studies suggest that fluoride exposure, especially during early development, may impact brain health and IQ. A study published in JAMA Pediatrics linked higher fluoride levels in pregnant women to lower IQ scores in their children.
- Dental Fluorosis: A condition caused by too much fluoride during childhood, leading to permanent discoloration or mottling of the teeth. Mild cases are cosmetic, but moderate to severe cases can damage enamel.
- Skeletal Fluorosis: High fluoride exposure over time may affect bones, making them brittle or more prone to fractures.
- Endocrine Disruption: Fluoride may interfere with the thyroid gland, which plays a major role in metabolism and hormone regulation.
And here’s the kicker: most of these risks are heightened in children – the very group that gets targeted the most with fluoride treatments. From the bubblegum-flavored fluoride trays at the dentist to fluoride drops in infancy, kids are routinely exposed at much higher levels relative to their body weight.
So, why is the dental industry still so on-board with fluoride? Especially when fluoride toothpastes come with a poison warning on the label.
Why Is the Industry Still So Stubborn?
Fluoride is deeply entrenched in dentistry. It’s part of the institutional identity. Admitting that it might pose risks means re-evaluating decades of recommendations, studies, public health policies, and even product development. That’s a big ask.
There’s also the issue of liability. If mainstream dental organizations started to warn about fluoride’s risks, imagine the public backlash. It would be like admitting they’d been wrong all along, which doesn’t go over well in any industry, especially not in healthcare.
And finally, let’s not forget the business side of things. Fluoride treatments are a billable service. Products with fluoride are a billion-dollar industry. Financial incentives don’t always align with better health outcomes, though, and that’s something we, as patients and consumers, need to recognize.
But Wait—Doesn’t Fluoride Actually Work?
It does help reduce cavities, particularly when applied topically (as in toothpaste). But the question isn’t if it works—it’s whether the benefits outweigh the risks, especially when there are safer, effective alternatives available.
Let’s also not forget that the modern rise in cavities isn’t just about fluoride. It’s about diet, lifestyle, mouth breathing, oral hygiene, and the health of the oral microbiome. You can’t out-fluoride a sugar-heavy, ultra-processed, acidic lifestyle. No toothpaste in the world is going to cancel out gummy worms and soda.
So what if we flipped the script? What if we focused more on prevention and remineralization from the inside out, and less on using a questionable chemical to patch up the damage?
There Is Another Way
Here’s the hopeful part: You can have strong, healthy teeth without fluoride. It just requires a more holistic (and slightly more thoughtful) approach. Here’s what that looks like:
1. Choose a Remineralizing Toothpaste (Without Fluoride)
Ingredients like micro-hydroxyapatite, a naturally occurring mineral that makes up 97% of your enamel, have shown great promise in strengthening teeth without the toxicity concerns. It works similarly to fluoride but in a more biocompatible way.
Other natural remineralizers like xylitol can also help keep your teeth strong and cavity-resistant.
2. Fix the Root Cause: Diet and Lifestyle
Cavities are caused by an imbalance in your oral environment. That means too much sugar, acidic foods, snacking throughout the day, and poor saliva quality (often from dehydration or mouth breathing).
Eating a mineral-rich diet (think leafy greens, bone broth, and dairy or alternatives), staying hydrated, and avoiding excessive sugar can do wonders for your enamel.
3. Support the Oral Microbiome
Your mouth is home to billions of bacteria—some good, some bad. Harsh mouthwashes and conventional toothpaste often kill off the good guys, which disrupts your oral ecosystem.
Instead, opt for toothpaste and oral care products that support a balanced microbiome, rather than sterilizing everything in sight.
4. Practice Smart Oral Hygiene
It sounds simple, but consistent brushing (with a soft bristle brush), flossing, tongue scraping, and nasal breathing can prevent the conditions that lead to decay. You don’t need chemicals—you need consistency.
So Where Do We Go from Here?
If you’re still using fluoride toothpaste and haven’t had any health issues, great. But it’s okay to question it. It’s okay to ask why children are being given high-dose fluoride treatments when their developing brains and bodies are most at risk. And it’s more than okay to look for safer options.
The dental field might be slow to change, but that doesn’t mean you have to be.
We’re finally waking up to the idea that health is whole-body, and the mouth is the gateway to that. It’s time oral care caught up to the rest of functional medicine. Fluoride might have been the best tool we had decades ago, but now we know better—and we can do better.
Your health choices should be informed, not just habitual. So next time you reach for toothpaste, ask yourself: Is this helping my teeth – or just numbing the symptoms of a bigger issue?
You deserve the full story.
Leave a Reply